The 8 Bed-in-a-box Brands We Stand Behind & Why

Maybe these mattresses will help us get our eight hours
August 18, 2019
August 18, 2019
No items found.
What We Considered
Our Picks

Everyone has their own version of self-care (masking, reading, bingeing the latest season of Stranger Things in one weekend), but if you ask us, self-care starts with feeling well-rested. You spend a third of your day sleeping (or you should at least...get those 8 hours!), and the quality of your sleep, and therefore your life, depends SO much on your mattress. 

The struggle is real when it comes to mattress shopping. Going to a store means dealing with pushy store representatives, haggling on prices, and still overpaying for your mattress. No thanks! Fortunately for us, mattress shopping has changed significantly over the last few years and we now have online brands that are making it easy to shop for mattresses without the traditional retail markup. Great, except now there are so many bed-in-a-box mattress brands that our heads are spinning, so let’s take 5 steps back. 

We’ve rounded up the 8 best bed-in-a-box brands? How? We started by stripping out the copycat brands, the opportunistic ones claiming to sell “Casper at half the price” (questionable and phony), and any that look like they belong on an infomercial (we’re not even sure what to do with that but it's not our thing). Then we took it one step further and got rid of the ones with insufficient reviews and fake Instagram followings that make you question what the hell is going on. That brings us down to 8 trusted brands that mean it when they say  their mattresses are superior. We know they stand behind their product, and their fanbases back them up too. 

Envision sleeping on clouds and bouncing amongst those fluffy pockets of air as you dream all night long. Every night. That’s the kind of good night’s sleep we’re talking about here. So get ready for the best sleep of your life - with real brands and fair prices.


Casper is one of the OGs when it comes to the new age of mattress shopping. Their dream started with designing an outrageously comfortable mattress and shipping it to your doorstep in a box. Fast forward a few years and Casper has grown to include physical Sleep Shops around the country. Hands up because they’ve expanded their product line to include bedding, pillows, and an innovative sleep lamp designed to help you fall asleep. They even make dog beds too, because your furry friends deserve the best.

The Goods

✓   Medium Firmness

✓   Three different styles available:The Wave, The Casper, & The Essential

✓   All-foam or hybrid options

✓   100 night risk-free trial

✓   10 year warranty

✓   In-store recycling for old bedding and mattresses

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   Commitment to community

✓   70,000+ sleep products donated to those in need of a bed 

✓   Recycle old beds, sheets & pillows & bedding  

✓   Committed to organizations like Start Small Think Big & Women In Need

Brentwood Home

The team behind Brentwood Home has been making mattresses with local artisans and fabricators in LA for over 30 years but decided to pivot their business in 2012 to a direct-to-consumer model. They've cut out the middleman, which means you can still benefit from their years of experience in mattress-making without overwhelming trips to the store. They've stuck to their California ethos of putting the environment first and using organic, non-toxic, and natural materials.

The Goods

✓   Generally on the plush side with firmer options

✓   7 mattress styles

✓   Vegan option available

✓   1 year risk-free trial

✓   Made in Los Angeles

✓  Mattress foundation available for purchase

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   Healthy materials that meet the Golden Standard

✓   Made in the USA in Cali

✓  Full transparency into their materials


Helix stands out from the rest by letting you customize your mattress, bringing you individualized comfort and support made just for you. Helix has got you no matter whether you’re a back sleeper, side sleeper or someone who tosses and turns all night. Take their sleep quiz to figure out exactly which mattress is right for you. We’re also crushing on their newly launched Birch mattresses line, a sister brand of organic mattress made of New Zealand wool and natural, non-toxic materials.

The Goods

✓   More on the firm side

✓   Customizable range of options

✓   Sleep quiz to help you pick the best one

✓   Organic version available through Birch

✓   100 night sleep trial

✓  25 year warranty

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   Made in the US 

✓   Options for every type of sleeper

✓  Organic mattress line, Birch, made of non-toxic materials


Tired of waking up sweaty AF? Us too. Leesa makes two versions of their mattress, an all-foam one and a hybrid foam + spring one, but you can bet that whichever one you pick will prevent those dreaded night sweats. Each mattress is topped with a responsive, cooling foam layer and a breathable plush cover. If that isn't enough to convince you, Leesa is also very committed to serving the community, which you can read all about in their 2018 Impact Report.

The Goods

✓   Generally on the firm side

✓   Two mattress options: Leesa Mattress & Leesa Hybrid Mattress 

✓   100 night guarantee

✓   10 year warranty

✓   Committed to community and the environment

✓  Breathable, cooling foam top layer

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   They donate one mattress for every ten sold (over 35,000 to date)

✓   Plant one tree for every mattress sold

✓  Made in the US

Parachute Home

You may already be familiar with Parachute's luxe yet affordable bedding that has taken the influencer world by storm, but they recently added a flagship mattress to their lineup as well (and if it's anything like their bedding, you know it’s GOOD). The mattress - which is very aptly called 'The Mattress' - skips latex and foam in favor of coils. This isn't anything like that spring mattress you bought off Craigslist while in college though (we've all been there). By mixing soft and firm coils, Parachute created different zones of firmness to make sure you're supported where you need to but still have that sinking-into-a-cloud feel. There's minimal motion transfer, so you can sleep through your partner getting in and out of bed in the middle of the night.

The Goods

✓   Firm in the center and more plush around the ends

✓   One mattress style: The Mattress

✓   Eco-friendly and foam free

✓   90 day trial

✓   10 year warranty

✓  Made of pure New Zealand Wool and 100% cotton

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   Responsibly manufactured

✓   No harmful chemicals of synthetics 

✓  Donates returned items to Habitat for Humanity

Tuft & Needle

Tuft & Needle was founded in 2012 when cofounder JT Marino realised that mattress shopping straight up sucked. After teaming up with Daehee Park, the duo set up a test site to see if people would even be interested in buying a mattress online (spoiler: people were very into it). In 2018, Tuft & Needle merged with Serta Simmons Bedding (you know, those guys who used to make all the mattresses before) to put over 220 combined years of knowledge and work towards disrupting the industry on a large scale.

The Goods

✓   Medium-firm

✓   Two types of mattresses: Original Mattress & Mint Mattress

✓   100 night trial

✓   10 year warranty

✓   Available at select stores

✓  Adaptive Foam provides comfy support while also being breathable

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   School fundraising program 

✓   $9M+ in mattresses donated back to the community

✓  1500+ volunteer hours


Allswell believes luxury sleep shouldn't come at luxury prices (Amen to that). Allswell mattresses are known for being a little firmer than some of the other bed-in-a-box brands out there. Their commitment is to their customers, and their end game is building loyalty and trust — even if that means risking profit to offer exceptional value and pricing. Their hybrid mattresses combine traditional mattress coil springs with layers of memory foam, so you get the best of both worlds for an exceptional sleep experience.

The Goods

✓   Medium firm

✓   Three mattress designs: The Allswell, The Luxe & The Supreme

✓   Self proclaimed firmness scale: 4.5-6.5 aka “just right”

✓   Hybrid foam and coil technology

✓   100 night risk-free trial

✓   Mattress haul-away option

✓  Works with a variety of bed setups

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   Donate mattresses to Good360

✓  70% of donations go to foster care to help homeless youth


Purple is over the memory foam bandwagon - instead they’ve developed their own technology, the Purple Grid, that’s rumored to be even better. Say goodbye to overheating at night (calling all blanket lovers who want to get cozy when it’s 90 degrees). This phenomenal mattress perfectly cradle our bods,  letting our spine feel true bliss night after night.

The Goods

✓   Medium support

✓   Purple grid technology

✓   Layered mattress for ultimate support

✓   Hyper-Elastic polymer purple grid is non-toxic and long-lasting

✓   Allows for maximum air-flow during our snoozes

✓   Available in regular, hybrid and hybrid premier

Why We Stand Behind Them

✓   Long-lasting and comfort tested

✓   Made in USA

Image Credits: Casper, @hellolaurennash @nicole.orduno @daniirey/ Brentwood Home, @brentwoodhome/ Helix, @helix Birch/ Leesa, @leesasleep @alovelybean @choosingchia/ Parachute, @ariellevey @parachutehome/ Tuft & Needle, @tuftandneedle/ Allswell, @allswellhome/ Wright Bedding,@wakeupwright/

At The Verticale, we’re here to help you find the internet’s best brands. We independently review each brand to see if they meet our standards, and then we create unique content to share them with you. The Verticale may earn commission if you buy something we link to from our site.